Story
Fragonard’s Young Girl Reading: the hidden face beneath
A girl in yellow lost in a book, painted fast and freely. In 2015 scientists found another woman underneath. The story, and choosing a print.

A girl in a lemon-yellow dress leans back against a big cushion, completely absorbed in a little book. Her collar, her ribbons and the folds of her sleeve are dashed in with fast, loose strokes, so the picture feels as fresh as the moment it shows. Jean-Honoré Fragonard painted it around 1769 or 1770. For two centuries nobody knew that underneath it lay a different painting.
A painting under the painting
In the 1980s an x-ray showed that there was another composition beneath the girl, but not what it was. In April 2015 the National Gallery of Art in Washington, which owns the picture, announced what its team had found. Using a near-infrared hyperspectral camera newly developed at the gallery, x-ray fluorescence scanning, digital x-rays and image-matching software from George Washington University, they rebuilt the hidden first version.
It was a complete painting in its own right, which they named Portrait of a Woman with a Book. It shows an older woman, not a girl, with her head turned to look straight out at the viewer. She wore a large feathered headdress dotted with colored beads and a thinner ruffle at her neck, and she was lit from the front. The first version seems to have existed, finished, for at least six months before Fragonard painted the reading girl over it.
The clue in a drawing
The breakthrough began with a drawing. In June 2012 a sheet by Fragonard came up at auction in Paris showing this very composition, but with the woman looking out at us. It linked the painting to a series of eighteen “fantasy figures,” made for a single commission. The team that solved the puzzle included Yuriko Jackall, John Delaney and Michael Swicklik of the National Gallery of Art and the Fragonard specialist Marie-Anne Dupuy-Vachey, and they published it in The Burlington Magazine.
Why did Fragonard change it?
Nobody knows for sure. What he made instead is more intimate. The first woman posed for us; the girl doesn’t know we are there. She is not performing, just reading, and that private absorption is what people have loved about the picture ever since.
How it is painted
Look closely and the speed of it is astonishing. The ruffled collar is a scribble of white. The ribbons are a few touches of lilac. The yellow silk is laid on in long sweeping strokes, and the cushion behind her in a handful of broad swipes. The face is painted more carefully than anything else, which pulls your eye straight to it.
Where is Young Girl Reading?
In the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. It was a gift in 1961 from Ailsa Mellon Bruce, in memory of her father, Andrew W. Mellon. The canvas is about 32 by 25½ inches.
Look closer
These details come from the scan we print from, made by the National Gallery of Art, 15,654 pixels on the long side. Pick a detail, or zoom in and drag to follow the brush.
A small red-edged book, its pages just a few quick strokes of white and gray.
Choosing a print
Life size. The canvas is about 32 by 25½ inches, and our 24 × 30 in framed print is very close to it; framed prints go up to 29 × 36 in. Framed prints go up to 29 × 36 in, canvas up to 32 × 40 in and unframed art prints up to 38 × 48 in.
The reading corner picture. It belongs beside a reading chair, in a library, a study or a child’s room, and it is a lovely gift for a reader or a teacher. At 13 × 16 in it fits beside a bookshelf. See our gift guide.
Which material. The brushwork is the point, and canvas, with its matte finish and no cover, gives it a painted feel. Smooth paper in a frame keeps every quick stroke crisp. See canvas and our papers.
Frames. Gold suits an 18th-century French picture and warms the yellow; a white frame makes it fresh and modern. See all our frames.
A Fragonard pair. Hang her calm with the flirtation of The Swing. Open the two as a set. Read the story of The Swing too.
Questions
What was found under Young Girl Reading?
An earlier, finished portrait of an older woman in a feathered headdress, looking out at the viewer. The National Gallery of Art announced it in 2015.
Who is the girl?
She has not been identified. The picture belongs to Fragonard’s series of “fantasy figures.”
Where is Young Girl Reading?
In the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C., since 1961.
How big is it?
81.1 × 64.8 cm, about 32 × 25½ in.
Can it be printed legally?
Yes. It was painted around 1770 and is in the public domain, and the National Gallery of Art shares its image freely. What public domain means.
More Fragonard, and readers
All Fragonard





More in Interiors and Portraits and Old Masters.
Sources
More from the Journal
Story · 7 minVan Gogh’s Starry Night: the facts, and choosing a print
Painted in June 1889 at an asylum in Provence: the view from his window, plus a village he made up. What is real, what it means, and which print to choose.
Story · 7 minThe Great Wave off Kanagawa: meaning, history and prints
A woodblock print, not a painting, and a storm wave, not a tsunami. What it shows, why no two impressions match, and how to choose a print.
Story · 7 minKlimt’s The Kiss: gold leaf, meaning and choosing a print
Real gold leaf on canvas, finished in 1909. The story of Klimt’s lovers, what a print can and can’t reproduce, and which size to choose.
Story · 7 min